I like to occasionally check the Rolling Stone list of the greatest singers of all time to look for updates and to get a sense of trends. Did you know that Blacks have gotten much better at singing since the last list was made? They now occupy all ten of the top ten slots, if we count biracial Mariah Carey. Despite a US population size that is roughly five times larger than that of Blacks, Whites simply cannot crack the top ten anymore. I suspect the answer for why Blacks are so much better is that St. George Floyd from his lofty palace in Heaven has blessed Blacks with voices even superior to those they enjoyed before Floyd's death.
Showing posts with label Racial Differences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Racial Differences. Show all posts
Friday, June 23, 2023
Friday, January 17, 2020
Race differences in drug dealing
What are the racial differences for drug sales? Arrest data for 2018 were provided by the FBI:
Percent of Arrests for Marijuana Manufacture/Sales
Black 44
White 52
Asian 2
Native American 1
According to the Census, blacks were 13% of Americans in 2018. The Census lumps Hispanics and whites together: They were 77% of Americans in 2018.
Based on these numbers, the black rate of marijuana sales is 5 times that of whites/Hispanics.
Percent Arrests for Opium or Cocaine Manufacture/Sales
Black 47
White 51
Asian 1
Native American 1
Using the same calculation, the black rate of opium/cocaine sales is 5 1/2 that of whites/Hispanics.
Percent Arrests for Other Dangerous Nonnarcotic Drug Sales
Black 19
White 78
Asian 1
Native American 1<1 font="">1>
Compared to whites/Hispanics, the rate of other dangerous drug sales by blacks is almost 1 1/2 times higher.
Percent Arrests for Synthetic Narcotic Sales
Black 21
White 78
Asian 1<1 font="">1>
Native American 1
Finally, the black rate for synthetic narcotic sales is 1.6 times that of whites/Hispanics.
Blacks surpass whites in all types of sales, especially opium, cocaine, and marijuana. Of course, with Asians being only 6% of the country, comparing them with blacks would reveal much larger differences.
Percent of Arrests for Marijuana Manufacture/Sales
Black 44
White 52
Asian 2
Native American 1
According to the Census, blacks were 13% of Americans in 2018. The Census lumps Hispanics and whites together: They were 77% of Americans in 2018.
Based on these numbers, the black rate of marijuana sales is 5 times that of whites/Hispanics.
Percent Arrests for Opium or Cocaine Manufacture/Sales
Black 47
White 51
Asian 1
Native American 1
Using the same calculation, the black rate of opium/cocaine sales is 5 1/2 that of whites/Hispanics.
Percent Arrests for Other Dangerous Nonnarcotic Drug Sales
Black 19
White 78
Asian 1
Native American 1<1 font="">1>
Compared to whites/Hispanics, the rate of other dangerous drug sales by blacks is almost 1 1/2 times higher.
Percent Arrests for Synthetic Narcotic Sales
Black 21
White 78
Asian 1<1 font="">1>
Native American 1
Finally, the black rate for synthetic narcotic sales is 1.6 times that of whites/Hispanics.
Blacks surpass whites in all types of sales, especially opium, cocaine, and marijuana. Of course, with Asians being only 6% of the country, comparing them with blacks would reveal much larger differences.
Thursday, January 16, 2020
Does the racial gap in fertility shrink in low-cost areas?
When it comes to having kids, it's possible that whites are more sensitive to the cost of living than are blacks or Hispanics. Perhaps the racial differences in fertility are smaller in inexpensive regions. Using General Social Survey (GSS) data, I calculated the mean number of offspring for women ages 40-59 during the years 2010-18. The GSS records the region of the country in which the respondent lives. There are nine regions: I decided to compare the Pacific (west coast) and West South Central (TX, LA, OK, AR) regions since the former is expensive while the latter is more affordable.
Mean number of offspring
Pacific
Hispanic 2.92
Black 2.08
White 1.75
West South Central
Hispanic 2.55
Black 2.27
White 2.11
As expected, Hispanic fertility is highest in both regions, while whites are on the bottom. While black and white women have more kids in the WSC region, Hispanic women in the Pacific have bigger families than Hispanics in the WSC, contrary to expectations.
Look at how the racial gap in the WSC is smaller than in the Pacific region. The Hispanic-white gap in the former is .44 kids, while it is 1.17 in the latter. Comparatively speaking, whites benefit from living in low-cost regions.
Do whites benefit when they move from a high-cost to an inexpensive region? The best I could do to answer this question with GSS data was to use a question about where you lived at age 16. I extended the time span to 2000-2018 to get a large enough sample size and focused on a move from the Pacific to the Mountain region since it was the most common expensive-to-cheap move.
Mean number of offspring--whites
Pacific to Mountain States 2.17
Stayed in Pacific 1.71
You can see that whites who lived in the Pacific region at age 16 but subsequently moved to the Mountain States averaged more kids than those who did not move out of the region. The move to cheaper regions seems to help fertility.
Mean number of offspring
Pacific
Hispanic 2.92
Black 2.08
White 1.75
West South Central
Hispanic 2.55
Black 2.27
White 2.11
As expected, Hispanic fertility is highest in both regions, while whites are on the bottom. While black and white women have more kids in the WSC region, Hispanic women in the Pacific have bigger families than Hispanics in the WSC, contrary to expectations.
Look at how the racial gap in the WSC is smaller than in the Pacific region. The Hispanic-white gap in the former is .44 kids, while it is 1.17 in the latter. Comparatively speaking, whites benefit from living in low-cost regions.
Do whites benefit when they move from a high-cost to an inexpensive region? The best I could do to answer this question with GSS data was to use a question about where you lived at age 16. I extended the time span to 2000-2018 to get a large enough sample size and focused on a move from the Pacific to the Mountain region since it was the most common expensive-to-cheap move.
Mean number of offspring--whites
Pacific to Mountain States 2.17
Stayed in Pacific 1.71
You can see that whites who lived in the Pacific region at age 16 but subsequently moved to the Mountain States averaged more kids than those who did not move out of the region. The move to cheaper regions seems to help fertility.
Sunday, October 06, 2019
Which race is most likely to enslave workers and to make sex slaves out of children?
In the last post, I showed that whites have a much lower rate of sex trafficking compared to other racial groups. Now let's look specifically at child sex and labor trafficking.
The numbers shown below compare the rates of child sex trafficking by non-whites to that of whites:
Times more likely to engage in child sex trafficking than whites
Blacks 14.6
Hispanics 5.3
Asians 3.1
Others 2.9
While the racial differences are not as large here as they were with all sex trafficking, they are still striking. All groups, especially blacks, are much more likely to traffic children.
Here are the differences for labor trafficking:
Times more likely to enslave workers than whites
Blacks 2.0
Hispanics 5.7
Asians 40.0
Others 83.0
The Asian/white gap is enormous and shouldn't surprise anyone. It's ironic that blacks are now two times more likely to enslave workers than whites. And look at "Others"--American Indians, Alaska Natives, Native Hawaiians, other Pacific Islanders, and persons of two or more races--the gap is giant.
White folks are just awful, aren't they?
Saturday, October 05, 2019
Guess which race has the highest rate of sex trafficking
The traditional way of looking at prostitution is being changed. Academics and criminal justice officials are moving to the concept of "sex trafficking" which stresses that the pimps (men) are the villains while the prostitutes (women) are the victims. Grown women, as well as underage girls, are assumed to be exploited. Criminal justice policy is also shifting toward greater punishment for Johns (men). The old pimp/prostitute understanding was insufficiently feminist.
Some police departments are devoting considerable resources to convict traffickers who could easily get 10 years behind bars for sex trafficking.
So who are the traffickers? Is the stereotype of the black pimp based in reality?
This Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) report gives the breakdown:
Percent of all trafficker suspects by race
Blacks 43.7
Hispanics 29.2
Asians 13.2
Whites 12.8
Other 1.2
I'll assume many of the "others" are American Indians. Of course, we need to adjust for group size. Since whites have the lowest rate, we'll make them the comparison group. The list below shows how many times a member of a given group is more likely to be a pimp than a white person:
Blacks 16.8
Hispanics 8.1
Asians 16.5
Others 6.0
Compared to whites, blacks are 16.8 times more likely to be pimps. That's a huge difference, but the difference is about as large for Asians. (I treated "Other" as Native Americans, but that is probably an inflated number since the category will include non-Natives).
Asians usually have the lowest crime rates (by far) but not here. My guess is that white men are much less likely to be pimps because they are more decent to women generally. In the next post, I'll look specifically at child and labor trafficking.
Some police departments are devoting considerable resources to convict traffickers who could easily get 10 years behind bars for sex trafficking.
So who are the traffickers? Is the stereotype of the black pimp based in reality?
This Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS) report gives the breakdown:
Percent of all trafficker suspects by race
Blacks 43.7
Hispanics 29.2
Asians 13.2
Whites 12.8
Other 1.2
I'll assume many of the "others" are American Indians. Of course, we need to adjust for group size. Since whites have the lowest rate, we'll make them the comparison group. The list below shows how many times a member of a given group is more likely to be a pimp than a white person:
Blacks 16.8
Hispanics 8.1
Asians 16.5
Others 6.0
Compared to whites, blacks are 16.8 times more likely to be pimps. That's a huge difference, but the difference is about as large for Asians. (I treated "Other" as Native Americans, but that is probably an inflated number since the category will include non-Natives).
Asians usually have the lowest crime rates (by far) but not here. My guess is that white men are much less likely to be pimps because they are more decent to women generally. In the next post, I'll look specifically at child and labor trafficking.
Saturday, September 21, 2019
Do Western populations place more value on self-sacrificing spousal love?
I'm currently reading the brand new book by Kevin MacDonald titled Individualism and the Western Liberal Tradition. I don't always agree with him, but I'm interested in anyone with big balls and interesting ideas.
According to MacDonald, Western populations evolved to value self-sacrificing love in prospective mates in order to cement close family environments and paternal investment in harsh northern environments. Since this is an element of a slow life-history strategy, East Asians should value this trait as well, while blacks should be shifted more toward short-term mating strategies.
The General Social Survey (GSS) asked American respondents how much they agree with four statements about loving one's partner with a deep, devoted, self-sacrificing type of love. I summed the answers to the four questions to create a scale (alpha coefficient = .83). (It's funny: as I write this, I'm hearing these lyrics on YouTube: "I dried your tears of pain, babe, A million times for you, I'd sell my soul for you babe, For money to burn with you, I'd give you all, and have none, babe.")
Next, I calculated the mean score for ethnic/racial groups with at least 20 respondents (sample size = 1,040). Here are the results:
Mean Love Score
Germans 13.98
Southern Europeans 13.77
American Indians 13.60
Mexicans 13.58
Italians 13.46
English/Welsh 13.38
Polish 13.38
Total Sample 13.37
Irish 13.32
Scottish 13.21
Scandinavians 13.08
East Asians 12.34
Blacks 11.84
Americans of German descent and southern Europeans are at the top of the list, while East Asians and blacks are at the bottom. The gap between Germans and blacks is seven-tenths of a standard deviation, a large difference.
Consistent with MacDonald's prediction, whites are in the top spot, and blacks are last. He doesn't focus on East Asians, but he relies on life-history theory, and East Asians should fit the "slow" strategy of high family investment.
The results seem somewhat cultural. I noticed that not only southern Europeans but Latin Americans (many nationalities were too small to make the list) tend to score high. This is consistent with the stereotype of the romantic Latin.
According to MacDonald, Western populations evolved to value self-sacrificing love in prospective mates in order to cement close family environments and paternal investment in harsh northern environments. Since this is an element of a slow life-history strategy, East Asians should value this trait as well, while blacks should be shifted more toward short-term mating strategies.
The General Social Survey (GSS) asked American respondents how much they agree with four statements about loving one's partner with a deep, devoted, self-sacrificing type of love. I summed the answers to the four questions to create a scale (alpha coefficient = .83). (It's funny: as I write this, I'm hearing these lyrics on YouTube: "I dried your tears of pain, babe, A million times for you, I'd sell my soul for you babe, For money to burn with you, I'd give you all, and have none, babe.")
Next, I calculated the mean score for ethnic/racial groups with at least 20 respondents (sample size = 1,040). Here are the results:
Mean Love Score
Germans 13.98
Southern Europeans 13.77
American Indians 13.60
Mexicans 13.58
Italians 13.46
English/Welsh 13.38
Polish 13.38
Total Sample 13.37
Irish 13.32
Scottish 13.21
Scandinavians 13.08
East Asians 12.34
Blacks 11.84
Americans of German descent and southern Europeans are at the top of the list, while East Asians and blacks are at the bottom. The gap between Germans and blacks is seven-tenths of a standard deviation, a large difference.
Consistent with MacDonald's prediction, whites are in the top spot, and blacks are last. He doesn't focus on East Asians, but he relies on life-history theory, and East Asians should fit the "slow" strategy of high family investment.
The results seem somewhat cultural. I noticed that not only southern Europeans but Latin Americans (many nationalities were too small to make the list) tend to score high. This is consistent with the stereotype of the romantic Latin.
Thursday, September 19, 2019
Does agricultural history of racial groups predict self-discipline?
Let me show you a typical move by a liberal researcher (redundant). Imagine you want to show that blacks face bias when applying for a job. A liberal propagandist will simply cite a statistic that blacks get turned down more often than whites as proof of discrimination.
The researcher knows that anyone with two brain cells will counter that, "There might be reasons other than bias that blacks are less likely to get the job. They might be less likely to have preferred qualifications like a college degree."
So the researcher does a statistical analysis that adjusts for education. When the racial effect persists, the analyst concludes that it is due to discrimination. An obvious problem with this approach is that it is assumed that race is a measure of bias. You assume what you're trying to demonstrate.
Having said that, I'm going to do exactly what the progressives do, only with my own preferred theory.
I wrote recently how Greg Cochran and Henry Harpending theorize that groups that have deeper histories of agriculture will differ in personality traits. They argue that success at farming requires the ability to plan for the long-term and the discipline to carry out the plan. If you eat your seed grain, you will have nothing to plant in the spring.
Length of agricultural goes like this from longest to shortest: Middle Eastern, Chinese/Europe, sub-Saharan African, and Native American. So the level of planning and discipline--called "conscientiousness" by personality researchers--should follow the same pattern. We don't have an adequate number of Middle Easterners in the General Social Survey sample, so let's include Jews to represent this group. We also add Hindus as another group with a long agricultural history.
The dependent variable in the regression model is years of education and the predictors include IQ plus dummies for all these ethnic groups. The idea behind the model is that one's education is determined by his IQ and his level conscientiousness. Once we adjust for IQ, if the ethnic dummies are still significantly related to education, this reflects conscientiousness. I chose blacks to be the reference group since they are a large group with a shorter (and more isolated) agricultural history, and so they should be toward the low end of conscientiousness.
Here are the results (sample size = 8,898):
Years of education (standardized OLS regression coefficients)
IQ 0.43***
Jewish 0.06****
East Asian 0.03***
Hindu 0.02
White 0.01
Hispanic -0.02*
Native American -0.07***
Other race -0.02
The results are dominated by IQ. It's a powerful predictor (contrary to what N.N. Taleb says. He would say IQ-like tests get you into the school, so it's circular, but the test doesn't finish your degree for you). Jews and East Asians finish more years of education than what is predicted by their IQs. Hispanics and especially Native Americans complete less schooling than their IQ's predict.
Following my approach, the data suggest that Jews and East Asians have high levels of consciousness, while Native Americans and Hispanics (who are part Native American) are significantly less conscientious than blacks--the reference group.
The researcher knows that anyone with two brain cells will counter that, "There might be reasons other than bias that blacks are less likely to get the job. They might be less likely to have preferred qualifications like a college degree."
So the researcher does a statistical analysis that adjusts for education. When the racial effect persists, the analyst concludes that it is due to discrimination. An obvious problem with this approach is that it is assumed that race is a measure of bias. You assume what you're trying to demonstrate.
Having said that, I'm going to do exactly what the progressives do, only with my own preferred theory.
I wrote recently how Greg Cochran and Henry Harpending theorize that groups that have deeper histories of agriculture will differ in personality traits. They argue that success at farming requires the ability to plan for the long-term and the discipline to carry out the plan. If you eat your seed grain, you will have nothing to plant in the spring.
Length of agricultural goes like this from longest to shortest: Middle Eastern, Chinese/Europe, sub-Saharan African, and Native American. So the level of planning and discipline--called "conscientiousness" by personality researchers--should follow the same pattern. We don't have an adequate number of Middle Easterners in the General Social Survey sample, so let's include Jews to represent this group. We also add Hindus as another group with a long agricultural history.
The dependent variable in the regression model is years of education and the predictors include IQ plus dummies for all these ethnic groups. The idea behind the model is that one's education is determined by his IQ and his level conscientiousness. Once we adjust for IQ, if the ethnic dummies are still significantly related to education, this reflects conscientiousness. I chose blacks to be the reference group since they are a large group with a shorter (and more isolated) agricultural history, and so they should be toward the low end of conscientiousness.
Here are the results (sample size = 8,898):
Years of education (standardized OLS regression coefficients)
IQ 0.43***
Jewish 0.06****
East Asian 0.03***
Hindu 0.02
White 0.01
Hispanic -0.02*
Native American -0.07***
Other race -0.02
The results are dominated by IQ. It's a powerful predictor (contrary to what N.N. Taleb says. He would say IQ-like tests get you into the school, so it's circular, but the test doesn't finish your degree for you). Jews and East Asians finish more years of education than what is predicted by their IQs. Hispanics and especially Native Americans complete less schooling than their IQ's predict.
Following my approach, the data suggest that Jews and East Asians have high levels of consciousness, while Native Americans and Hispanics (who are part Native American) are significantly less conscientious than blacks--the reference group.
Saturday, September 14, 2019
Liking classical music: Is it a racial or an IQ thing?
It gives me hope that every time I turn the dial to a rock 'n' roll station, my boys complain and insist I put on some classical music. I tell them Led Zeppelin IS classical music, but they'll have none of it.
What predicts best a fondness for classical music: race or intelligence?
The General Social Survey (GSS) asked people how much they like classical music with answer-choices ranging from "like very much" to "dislike very much." With race and IQ as predictors, I used ordinary least squares (OLS) regression to generate estimates. Here are the standardized coefficients (sample size = 916):
Standardized OLS coefficients
IQ 0.31***
Black 0.02
Other non-whites 0.02
***p < .001
The only predictor that matters is IQ: smart people are much more likely to enjoy classical music than dull ones. Blacks tend to not like this type of music (results not shown here), but once you adjust for IQ, the race effect disappears. In other words, the reason why fewer blacks are classic music fans is completely due to lower intelligence. Other races do not differ from whites (results not shown), even before you adjust for IQ.
So, taste in music is more an IQ than a race thing. This might be true of many preferences among Americans.
UPDATE: Immigration and dysgenic trends in fertility are gradually lowering the mean IQ in the United States, so at this rate, we will see falling interest in great music. Bring on the Ranchera!
What predicts best a fondness for classical music: race or intelligence?
The General Social Survey (GSS) asked people how much they like classical music with answer-choices ranging from "like very much" to "dislike very much." With race and IQ as predictors, I used ordinary least squares (OLS) regression to generate estimates. Here are the standardized coefficients (sample size = 916):
Standardized OLS coefficients
IQ 0.31***
Black 0.02
Other non-whites 0.02
***p < .001
The only predictor that matters is IQ: smart people are much more likely to enjoy classical music than dull ones. Blacks tend to not like this type of music (results not shown here), but once you adjust for IQ, the race effect disappears. In other words, the reason why fewer blacks are classic music fans is completely due to lower intelligence. Other races do not differ from whites (results not shown), even before you adjust for IQ.
So, taste in music is more an IQ than a race thing. This might be true of many preferences among Americans.
UPDATE: Immigration and dysgenic trends in fertility are gradually lowering the mean IQ in the United States, so at this rate, we will see falling interest in great music. Bring on the Ranchera!
Thursday, September 12, 2019
Which races are the most generous? It might surprise you.
It's the 10th anniversary of 10,000 Year Explosion, a fantastic book by Gregory Cochran and the late Henry Harpending. You MUST read it if you haven't. I command you.
The book is chock full of provocative hypotheses about humans. Let's test just one of them with General Social Survey (GSS) data. The authors explain that hunter-gatherers routinely share resources, in part because it is difficult for mobile people to hold on to things. It's also advantageous to cement positive ties and to make others feel obligated to you by being generous with them.
By contrast, farming selects for people who are good at holding on to possessions: seed grain, breeding stock, land, etc. A farmer who gives away everything will starve.
So Cochran and Harpending predict that ethnic groups lacking deep histories of agriculture will tend to be quicker to share with others. In the US context, this would be American Indians and blacks.
The GSS asked respondents: "People help other people in ways besides giving money, time, or other things to organized groups. Sometimes people help needy people directly. During the past 12 months, did you or members of your family or household give money, food, or clothing to any of the following types of people: The homeless or street-people."
Here are the percentages who answered yes:
Percent giving to the homeless in the past year
American Indian 55.4
Blacks 45.7
Irish 44.0
East Asian 41.7
Total sample 40.2
Mexican 39.4
Italian 37.7
French 37.0
Russian 36.8
German 34.2
English/Welsh 33.1
Scottish 30.4
Asian Indian 28.6
Norwegian 20.0
Even though American Indians and blacks are poor groups, they are more likely to give to the homeless. Groups with long agricultural histories are less likely to give, even if they are wealthy like Asian Indians.
And if you argue that giving to the homeless is largely an urban thing, American Indians tend to live in rural areas but are at the top of the list, while urban Asian Indians are at the bottom.
The book is chock full of provocative hypotheses about humans. Let's test just one of them with General Social Survey (GSS) data. The authors explain that hunter-gatherers routinely share resources, in part because it is difficult for mobile people to hold on to things. It's also advantageous to cement positive ties and to make others feel obligated to you by being generous with them.
By contrast, farming selects for people who are good at holding on to possessions: seed grain, breeding stock, land, etc. A farmer who gives away everything will starve.
So Cochran and Harpending predict that ethnic groups lacking deep histories of agriculture will tend to be quicker to share with others. In the US context, this would be American Indians and blacks.
The GSS asked respondents: "People help other people in ways besides giving money, time, or other things to organized groups. Sometimes people help needy people directly. During the past 12 months, did you or members of your family or household give money, food, or clothing to any of the following types of people: The homeless or street-people."
Here are the percentages who answered yes:
Percent giving to the homeless in the past year
American Indian 55.4
Blacks 45.7
Irish 44.0
East Asian 41.7
Total sample 40.2
Mexican 39.4
Italian 37.7
French 37.0
Russian 36.8
German 34.2
English/Welsh 33.1
Scottish 30.4
Asian Indian 28.6
Norwegian 20.0
Even though American Indians and blacks are poor groups, they are more likely to give to the homeless. Groups with long agricultural histories are less likely to give, even if they are wealthy like Asian Indians.
And if you argue that giving to the homeless is largely an urban thing, American Indians tend to live in rural areas but are at the top of the list, while urban Asian Indians are at the bottom.
Saturday, August 24, 2019
You've got two kinds of people (or perhaps four)
Richard Lynn's new book Race Differences in Psychopathic Personality makes a convincing case that blacks and American Indians score high on exploitativeness (my term) while Asians tend to be the opposite--let's call this "fairness." Whites are closer to Asians, while Hispanics are what you would expect as a hybrid of white and Native American.
People who accept human biodiversity (HBD) tend to focus on general intelligence, and for good reason: it is very important for individuals, societies, and for all of humanity. But let me also stress the importance of this exploitativeness-fairness continuum. Your life will be better if you deal with people who are smart and fair rather than cunning and exploitative.
So this leads to a typology of four kinds of people: 1) smart-fair, 2) smart-exploitative, 3) dumb-fair, and 4) dumb-exploitative. I don't know about you, but I've known plenty of examples of each, but the situation tends to actually get simpler in the aggregate because at this level smart and fair tend to go together. Asians as a group not only score low on psychopathy, they are also highly intelligent. Blacks tend to be exploitative and unintelligent. So at the macrolevel, there is a tendency toward two types: more contributive and less contributive people.
You might counter that history shows lots of Asian exploitativeness. The Rape of Nanking, etc., etc. Humans treat each other horribly all the time, but my contention is that the average traits of people have an important impact on the quality of a society. A key reason why Japan is a better country than Nigeria is that it has a higher prevalence of intelligent, fair people.
People who accept human biodiversity (HBD) tend to focus on general intelligence, and for good reason: it is very important for individuals, societies, and for all of humanity. But let me also stress the importance of this exploitativeness-fairness continuum. Your life will be better if you deal with people who are smart and fair rather than cunning and exploitative.
So this leads to a typology of four kinds of people: 1) smart-fair, 2) smart-exploitative, 3) dumb-fair, and 4) dumb-exploitative. I don't know about you, but I've known plenty of examples of each, but the situation tends to actually get simpler in the aggregate because at this level smart and fair tend to go together. Asians as a group not only score low on psychopathy, they are also highly intelligent. Blacks tend to be exploitative and unintelligent. So at the macrolevel, there is a tendency toward two types: more contributive and less contributive people.
You might counter that history shows lots of Asian exploitativeness. The Rape of Nanking, etc., etc. Humans treat each other horribly all the time, but my contention is that the average traits of people have an important impact on the quality of a society. A key reason why Japan is a better country than Nigeria is that it has a higher prevalence of intelligent, fair people.
Thursday, August 22, 2019
Occam's Razor demands the simplest explanation: races are internally different
Richard Lynn's new book Race Differences in Psychopathic Personality describes hundreds of studies conducted around the world. One American study that strikes me is a simple one of racial differences in doing one's homework that is described on page 61.
The mean number of hours studied per week by high school seniors looks like this: Asians, 3.9; whites, 3.4; Hispanics and blacks, 2.0. Asian teens study roughly twice as much as other minorities.
Academic apologists work full-time concocting reasons for the racial gaps we see, but how do we blame homework differences on malevolent, discriminatory whites? Homework is done at home with no whites looking over your shoulder. The schools provide even poor minority kids with books and materials for assignments. Parents and kids simply decide how much time gets devoted to studying.
You might respond that minority kids are given less homework because of the "bigotry of low expectations." But why do Asians do more than whites? If you answer that schools are just following stereotypes, so schools with lots of Asian students assign more homework, it simply starts to seem like schools might respond to what students are like, or hardworking families select schools with higher expectations.
It just becomes absurd to pin these racial gaps on anything at all bad that whites do. Again and again, we see that whites are mediocre. What sort of white supremacist country sorts whites into the undistinguished middle? I want a better brand of supremacy!
After reading Lynn's descriptions on more than 700 studies from dozens of countries, Occam's Razor demands the simplest explanation: the races are internally different.
The mean number of hours studied per week by high school seniors looks like this: Asians, 3.9; whites, 3.4; Hispanics and blacks, 2.0. Asian teens study roughly twice as much as other minorities.
Academic apologists work full-time concocting reasons for the racial gaps we see, but how do we blame homework differences on malevolent, discriminatory whites? Homework is done at home with no whites looking over your shoulder. The schools provide even poor minority kids with books and materials for assignments. Parents and kids simply decide how much time gets devoted to studying.
You might respond that minority kids are given less homework because of the "bigotry of low expectations." But why do Asians do more than whites? If you answer that schools are just following stereotypes, so schools with lots of Asian students assign more homework, it simply starts to seem like schools might respond to what students are like, or hardworking families select schools with higher expectations.
It just becomes absurd to pin these racial gaps on anything at all bad that whites do. Again and again, we see that whites are mediocre. What sort of white supremacist country sorts whites into the undistinguished middle? I want a better brand of supremacy!
After reading Lynn's descriptions on more than 700 studies from dozens of countries, Occam's Razor demands the simplest explanation: the races are internally different.
Friday, August 02, 2019
Data: Almost one-quarter of black men are exploitative compared to ZERO percentage of Chinese men
A recent post focused on racial differences in psychopathy, and while people know the obvious connection between being a psychopath and committing crimes, few realize that the correlation between a promiscuous lifestyle and psychopathy is about as strong. In fact, a lifestyle of casual sex is one criterion for diagnosing psychopathic personality. Evolutionary psychologists have developed the concept of sociosexuality, which refers to an interest in non-committal sex. The correlation between sociosexuality and psychopathy is roughly 0.4, an impressive number. It's strong enough that factor analysis would probably reveal one supertrait that underlies psychopathy, criminality, and sociosexuality--a syndrome we could call exploitativeness.
So, are there racial and ethnic differences in sociosexuality or exploitativeness (as indicated by high sociosexuality)? The General Social Survey does have one item used in sociosexuality inventories--the number of sexual partners since age 18. Let's pick an arbitrary cutoff--25+ partners--to indicate exploitativeness. For now, I will focus on men and will limit analysis to ethnic groups with at least 50 respondents (sample size = 10,789):
Percent with 25+ sexual partners since age 18
Black 24.3
Scottish 19.8
Spanish 19.7
Jewish 19.1
American Indian 18.2
Greek 18.2
Italian 16.6
Puerto Rican 15.7
Other Spanish 14.9
Norwegian 14.6
Irish 14.4
Percent for total sample 14.1
Russian 13.9
French 13.5
English/Welsh 12.9
Austrian 11.5
Polish 11.4
German 11.2
French Canadian 10.2
Swedish 10.1
Dutch 9.9
Mexican 8.7
Danish 8.2
Czech 7.8
Asian Indian 4.1
Filipino 3.3
Chinese 0.0
You can see that by selecting a cutoff of 25 partners, this gives us 14.1% of US men being exploitative. More importantly for this post, we see tremendous diversity in this trait. Almost one-quarter of black men are exploitative compared to ZERO Chinese men. Looking at general patterns, Southern Europeans tend to have higher numbers, while Asians fall to the bottom. These patterns are consistent with numbers presented in Richard Lynn's Race Differences in Psychopathic Personality. He found high psychopathy among blacks and American Indians, moderate levels among whites, and low levels among Asians.
So, are there racial and ethnic differences in sociosexuality or exploitativeness (as indicated by high sociosexuality)? The General Social Survey does have one item used in sociosexuality inventories--the number of sexual partners since age 18. Let's pick an arbitrary cutoff--25+ partners--to indicate exploitativeness. For now, I will focus on men and will limit analysis to ethnic groups with at least 50 respondents (sample size = 10,789):
Percent with 25+ sexual partners since age 18
Black 24.3
Scottish 19.8
Spanish 19.7
Jewish 19.1
American Indian 18.2
Greek 18.2
Italian 16.6
Puerto Rican 15.7
Other Spanish 14.9
Norwegian 14.6
Irish 14.4
Percent for total sample 14.1
Russian 13.9
French 13.5
English/Welsh 12.9
Austrian 11.5
Polish 11.4
German 11.2
French Canadian 10.2
Swedish 10.1
Dutch 9.9
Mexican 8.7
Danish 8.2
Czech 7.8
Asian Indian 4.1
Filipino 3.3
Chinese 0.0
You can see that by selecting a cutoff of 25 partners, this gives us 14.1% of US men being exploitative. More importantly for this post, we see tremendous diversity in this trait. Almost one-quarter of black men are exploitative compared to ZERO Chinese men. Looking at general patterns, Southern Europeans tend to have higher numbers, while Asians fall to the bottom. These patterns are consistent with numbers presented in Richard Lynn's Race Differences in Psychopathic Personality. He found high psychopathy among blacks and American Indians, moderate levels among whites, and low levels among Asians.
Wednesday, July 17, 2019
Which ethnic groups think astrology is scientific?
It is important for America that we have people who understand and value science. The General Social Survey asked people residing in the US, "Would you say that astrology is very scientific, sort of scientific, or not at all scientific?" Anyone who understands science would not say astrology is scientific, even if they otherwise like it.
Let's look at the percentage who say astrology is very or sort of scientific listed by ethnic group (sample size = 6,873):
Percent who say astrology is scientific
Black 53.1
Mexican 50.6
Asian Indian 47.4
Puerto Rican 46.4
American Indian 45.1
Filipino 42.7
Spanish 41.2
Norwegian 38.5
All Americans 36.3
Chinese 35.5
Italian 35.1
Portuguese 34.3
Arab 32.1
Irish 31.1
French Canadian 30.8
Polish 29.9
French 29.5
Dutch 29.2
German 28.9
Japanese 28.5
Czech 27.7
Swiss 27.5
Russian 27.0
Greek 25.0
Scottish 24.3
Jewish 23.8
English 23.5
Danish 21.1
Swedish 15.1
Blacks, Hispanics, and American Indians top the list, but some high IQ ethnic groups are toward the top as well; namely, Asian Indians, Norwegians, and Chinese. Setting aside the Norwegians, there is a tendency for northwestern Europeans to fall to the bottom of the list. These groups are more skeptical and seem to understand better what it means to be scientific.
Let's look at the percentage who say astrology is very or sort of scientific listed by ethnic group (sample size = 6,873):
Percent who say astrology is scientific
Black 53.1
Mexican 50.6
Asian Indian 47.4
Puerto Rican 46.4
American Indian 45.1
Filipino 42.7
Spanish 41.2
Norwegian 38.5
All Americans 36.3
Chinese 35.5
Italian 35.1
Portuguese 34.3
Arab 32.1
Irish 31.1
French Canadian 30.8
Polish 29.9
French 29.5
Dutch 29.2
German 28.9
Japanese 28.5
Czech 27.7
Swiss 27.5
Russian 27.0
Greek 25.0
Scottish 24.3
Jewish 23.8
English 23.5
Danish 21.1
Swedish 15.1
Blacks, Hispanics, and American Indians top the list, but some high IQ ethnic groups are toward the top as well; namely, Asian Indians, Norwegians, and Chinese. Setting aside the Norwegians, there is a tendency for northwestern Europeans to fall to the bottom of the list. These groups are more skeptical and seem to understand better what it means to be scientific.
Sunday, July 14, 2019
Why would an animal programmed to survive and reproduce care so much about right and wrong?
In a recent post, I critiqued Richard Wrangham's theory of why humans are so much less violent than our cousins, the chimpanzees. In The Goodness Paradox, he also attempts to explain why we have a strong moral sense. It's strange for an animal designed to outcompete others through survival and greater reproductive success to care so much about abstract concepts of right and wrong.
He hypothesizes that human society changed fundamentally when men developed the language to coordinate control over other members of the group. While apes sometimes gang up and beat or kill a single, obnoxious ape, they don't plan it out ahead of time. Men gained a tremendous tool when they began to conspire as a group of five or six against one. They could discuss the idea, plan a surprise attack, and kill the offender with little danger to themselves. Sometimes the murder wasn't necessary: A rumor could be floated and the troublemaker might be convinced to change his ways.
Wrangham claims that men expanded their control to all members of the community so that everybody was were in fear of their ability to conduct a surprise attack against them. Over evolutionary time, humans were selected for their ability to please the men who had this power over them. Extremely selfish, exploitative people were weeded out. A person who treated everyone well was unlikely to displease elders, so prosociality became a more and more common trait. And while I didn't find Wrangham clear on this point, I think moral values gradually developed as a reflection of the prosocial personalities that were becoming common.
According to Wrangham, selection has been more successful at producing people oriented toward having a good reputation and appearing moral rather than creating humans of deep, genuine integrity and principle. After all, we are still programmed to care about our own reproductive interests.
I would return to my earlier criticism: In 2019, some groups seem to have much higher rates of prosociality than others. For example, a quick look at the Corruption Perceptions Index reveals that Denmark has very little public corruption compared to Somalia. How does Wrangham help us explain the enormous gulf between the two countries? He doesn't. He presents the image of all human groups across the globe being identical in terms of genes that contribute to cooperativeness. I suppose he would say that evolutionary biology tells the story up until the day before yesterday, but now it's irrelevant: It's all sociology now. Not credible.
Wednesday, July 10, 2019
Richard Wrangham works hard to explain the violence gap we don't care about
Urban Americans worry quite a bit about violence in their cities. Many of these places will rack up hundreds of homicides per year. Urban black men face a pretty decent chance of being murdered. So it was weird to read Richard Wrangham's new book The Goodness Paradox with its central claim that humans are very peaceful.
How could he have this view? Well, he has studied chimps for decades. Contrary to stories told by liberal primatologists in the 1960s, it turns out that chimps are mean bastards. If you stuffed 200 of them into Boeing 737, by the end of the flight many would be murdered. The human homicide rate is a tiny fraction of that seen among chimpanzees.
Wrangham then sets out to develop a theory to explain why we are so slow to lose our cool and attack others. He claims that when our ancestors developed the ability for fairly sophisticated language about 300-500k years ago, men in a group began to handle their antisocial members by plotting to murder them. Chimps will sometimes gang up on a cantankerous alpha and take him out, but it is spontaneous. No planning is involved.
Men gained great power over individuals by using premeditated, coalitionary aggression against not only bullies but eventually against all non-conformists. Over evolutionary time, this selected for humans who were motivated to get along with others and who were particularly interested in pleasing tribal elders--the men who had the power to kill them if they become sufficiently annoyed.
In developing his theory, Wrangham did exactly what I expected from a PC biologist: He avoids discussions of why human groups currently vary so much in their levels of homicide. Some educated person reading his book wants to know why his neighborhood is so much safer than the black neighborhood on the other side of town. The homicide rate in Colombia, for example, is scores of times higher than in Japan. Why? Wrangham is silent on this type of issue. He makes it sound like humanity has experienced the exact same selection pressures for hundreds of thousands of years, and that we all arrive at 2019 exactly the same in terms of genetic propensity for violence. He admits that the speed of selection probably increased in more recent millennia, but is silent about what that means.
Wrangham also fails to discuss the scholarship of Greg Cochran, Henry Harpending, and Peter Frost which suggests that pacification of some human groups has happened over the past few thousand years. I guess I would be silent on such topics, too, if I valued my lofty perch at the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology at Harvard University.
Sunday, April 14, 2019
Data: If Taleb is right that IQ is a BS measure, why do higher scorers have big brains? And why the perfect racial rankings?
A 2015 meta-analysis of 88 studies found that the correlation between human brain volume and intelligence is .24, a small-to-moderate size relationship. In new research that re-analyzed the data from the 2015 study, the authors showed that the strength of the link depends on how well IQ is measured and the degree to which studies include a full range of values for brain volume and IQ (For example, if only college students are included, many lower IQ people will be excluded, and this will shrink the correlation.)
Based on their analysis, the researchers estimated that the true brain volume/IQ correlation is around .40 -- a fairly strong correlation.
Keep in mind that many researchers have reported racial differences in brain volume that match up with IQ differences. Rushton and Ankney (2009) summarized the research. For example, Beals et al. (1984) measured the endocranial volumes of close to 20,000 skulls from around the world. The Asian-black gap was reported to be a roughly 150 cubic centimeter advantage for Asians.
If IQ is BS measure like Nassim Taleb says, why do high scorers have big brains?
Based on their analysis, the researchers estimated that the true brain volume/IQ correlation is around .40 -- a fairly strong correlation.
Keep in mind that many researchers have reported racial differences in brain volume that match up with IQ differences. Rushton and Ankney (2009) summarized the research. For example, Beals et al. (1984) measured the endocranial volumes of close to 20,000 skulls from around the world. The Asian-black gap was reported to be a roughly 150 cubic centimeter advantage for Asians.
If IQ is BS measure like Nassim Taleb says, why do high scorers have big brains?
Friday, March 01, 2019
Data: Do liberals secretly desire the destruction of blacks?
Author Philip Roth provides a good example of the how the Left feels about sex. In his novels, he celebrates infidelity. He loves it, and says that the man who invented faithfulness should never be forgiven.
He's probably not smart enough to see it, but he who loves cheating evidently loves murder, too, because infidelity is a major cause of homicide. The case of the murderous jealous partner is only too common.
Cheating and murder are problems for all populations, but they are particular problems among blacks. The General Social Survey asked participants, "Have you ever had sex with someone other than your husband or wife while you were married?" Here are the percentages who answered yes (sample size = 20,205):
Men
Blacks 33.8
Whites 21.9
Relative risk 1.5
Women
Blacks 18.6
Whites 13.5
Relative risk
Relative risk 1.4
So black men are 1.5 times more likely to cheat than white men; the black/white gap for women is similar.
The black homicide rate runs about 8 times that of whites, and some of this difference is due to greater infidelity among blacks. (The data here only addresses marriage, but I assume the racial difference in cheating between single blacks and whites is similar).
Do liberals secretly desire the destruction of blacks? They've helped destroy the black family by subsidizing single motherhood, they favor abortion on demand which eliminates a much higher rate of black babies than whites, and they favor sexual deviance which encourages murder.
He's probably not smart enough to see it, but he who loves cheating evidently loves murder, too, because infidelity is a major cause of homicide. The case of the murderous jealous partner is only too common.
Cheating and murder are problems for all populations, but they are particular problems among blacks. The General Social Survey asked participants, "Have you ever had sex with someone other than your husband or wife while you were married?" Here are the percentages who answered yes (sample size = 20,205):
Men
Blacks 33.8
Whites 21.9
Relative risk 1.5
Women
Blacks 18.6
Whites 13.5
Relative risk
Relative risk 1.4
So black men are 1.5 times more likely to cheat than white men; the black/white gap for women is similar.
The black homicide rate runs about 8 times that of whites, and some of this difference is due to greater infidelity among blacks. (The data here only addresses marriage, but I assume the racial difference in cheating between single blacks and whites is similar).
Do liberals secretly desire the destruction of blacks? They've helped destroy the black family by subsidizing single motherhood, they favor abortion on demand which eliminates a much higher rate of black babies than whites, and they favor sexual deviance which encourages murder.
Friday, February 22, 2019
Data: Are there racial differences in honesty?
Jussie Smollett is just the most recent case of the common phenomenon of minorities orchestrating a hate hoax. This raises the more general question whether racial/ethnic/religious groups differ in how much they value honesty. General Social Survey respondents (all living in America) were asked how much they prioritize various qualities in children. One of the qualities is honesty. Answers ranged from "most desirable" (5) to "least desirable (1)."
I calculated means for various groups (N = 6,279):
Mean Honesty Score
Filipino 4.28
Japanese 4.25
Finnish 4.21
Portuguese 4.19
Dutch 4.15
Swiss 4.15
French Canadian 4.14
English/Welsh 4.12
Irish 4.12
Scotland 4.12
German 4.10
Chinese 4.08
Czech 4.08
French 4.08
Asian Indian 4.08
Total Sample 4.08
Danish 4.06
Norwegian 4.05
Italian 4.02
Austrian 4.00
Lithuanian 3.97
Swedish 3.95
American Indian 3.92
Belgian 3.92
Polish 3.92
Spanish 3.92
Jewish 3.90
Hungarian 3.87
Russian 3.79
Romanian 3.79
Black 3.78
Mexican 3.76
West Indian 3.65
Greek 3.47
Certain minorities -- Jews, blacks, Mex-Ams, and West Indians -- have low honesty scores. The difference between the most honest (Filipinos) and least honest (Greeks) is close to one standard deviation, a very large difference.
There is a tendency for southern and eastern Europeans to value honesty less, while northwestern Europeans and Asians tend to have higher means (though there are exceptions). (I didn't have enough cases of Muslims or Arabs to calculate estimates.)
I calculated means for various groups (N = 6,279):
Mean Honesty Score
Filipino 4.28
Japanese 4.25
Finnish 4.21
Portuguese 4.19
Dutch 4.15
Swiss 4.15
French Canadian 4.14
English/Welsh 4.12
Irish 4.12
Scotland 4.12
German 4.10
Chinese 4.08
Czech 4.08
French 4.08
Asian Indian 4.08
Total Sample 4.08
Danish 4.06
Norwegian 4.05
Italian 4.02
Austrian 4.00
Lithuanian 3.97
Swedish 3.95
American Indian 3.92
Belgian 3.92
Polish 3.92
Spanish 3.92
Jewish 3.90
Hungarian 3.87
Russian 3.79
Romanian 3.79
Black 3.78
Mexican 3.76
West Indian 3.65
Greek 3.47
Certain minorities -- Jews, blacks, Mex-Ams, and West Indians -- have low honesty scores. The difference between the most honest (Filipinos) and least honest (Greeks) is close to one standard deviation, a very large difference.
There is a tendency for southern and eastern Europeans to value honesty less, while northwestern Europeans and Asians tend to have higher means (though there are exceptions). (I didn't have enough cases of Muslims or Arabs to calculate estimates.)
Thursday, June 28, 2018
Details on wolves and coyotes
We saw in the recent post that a statistic, the fixation index, that measures the genetic distance between two populations indicates that Europeans and sub-Saharan Africans are as far apart as wolves and coyotes.
This is a useful comparison because, while it is hard for humans to look at race without bias, who cares about wolves and coyotes?
I looked at Walker's Carnivores of the World to see what is says about these two species. Notice how I used the term species. Canis latrans (coyotes) and Canis lupus (gray wolves). The simple fact that blacks and whites are different as two (closely related) species is stunning. Coyotes and wolves interbreed, but biologists consider them separate species. But let's get specific.
First of all, the two species are obviously similar. Many of the major traits one would think of for one species is true for the other: carnivorous, keen sense of smell, cooperative hunting, etc. The two species live out their lives in very similar ways. So do blacks and whites.
But the two species are for from identical. Wolves are much larger: head and body length are 1,000 to 1,600 mm compared with coyotes at 750-1,000 mm. Wolves' tails are 350 to 560 mm, while those of coyotes are 300-400 mm. Coyotes have a narrower build, proportionally longer ears, and a much narrower snout. At birth, coyotes average 250 grams; for wolves, it's 450 grams. Coyotes appear to reach sexual maturity earlier than wolves, and their maximum longevity is 1.5 years shorter (14.5 vs. 16 years).
You might counter that perhaps they differ physically, but the real question is behavior, and the two behave the same. Not so. Wolves are more social. They run in significantly larger packs, they engage in cooperative hunting more often and on a larger scale, and they target much bigger game. While coyotes focus on rabbits and rodents, wolves don't focus on anything smaller than a beaver. They take down deer, moose, wapiti, caribou, bison, muskox, mountain sheep, etc.
Coyotes focus much more on scavenging. They are more likely to hunt alone or in pairs, and will even partner up with a badger. The coyote uses his superior nose to sniff out a rodent, while the badger uses his superior claws to dig up the meal they split. Coyotes can prey on sheep, but wolves also go after larger animals that are important to humans: cattle and reindeer.
The home range of wolves is much larger: the book reports a maximum of 13,000 sq km for wolves, but only 80 km for coyotes. Wolves need much more space: They can't get more dense than one wolf per 26 sq km while coyotes get as high as 2 per sq km.
You might counter again that behavioral differences in animals may be influenced by genes, but humans are controlled by culture. Over the years, I've read a number of studies on the heritability of animal behavior. It's often been of rodents--not known for their rich culture. I was stunned to learn that human conduct is influenced by genes just as much as that of animals. Heritabilities for animal behavior typically run from .2 to .4. Studies often give heritabilities for humans higher than that.
To see who we are more clearly, we have got to look at ourselves like we look at coyotes and wolves; as animals, plain and simple.
UPDATE: To clarify, I suspect that the environment is not as important for animal behavior as the heritability studies suggest. For both human and animal studies, anything not genetic gets thrown into the environment component, but it likely contains a lot of measurement error, random noise, and other factors that probably cannot be changed like the term "environment" suggests.
This is a useful comparison because, while it is hard for humans to look at race without bias, who cares about wolves and coyotes?
I looked at Walker's Carnivores of the World to see what is says about these two species. Notice how I used the term species. Canis latrans (coyotes) and Canis lupus (gray wolves). The simple fact that blacks and whites are different as two (closely related) species is stunning. Coyotes and wolves interbreed, but biologists consider them separate species. But let's get specific.
First of all, the two species are obviously similar. Many of the major traits one would think of for one species is true for the other: carnivorous, keen sense of smell, cooperative hunting, etc. The two species live out their lives in very similar ways. So do blacks and whites.
But the two species are for from identical. Wolves are much larger: head and body length are 1,000 to 1,600 mm compared with coyotes at 750-1,000 mm. Wolves' tails are 350 to 560 mm, while those of coyotes are 300-400 mm. Coyotes have a narrower build, proportionally longer ears, and a much narrower snout. At birth, coyotes average 250 grams; for wolves, it's 450 grams. Coyotes appear to reach sexual maturity earlier than wolves, and their maximum longevity is 1.5 years shorter (14.5 vs. 16 years).
You might counter that perhaps they differ physically, but the real question is behavior, and the two behave the same. Not so. Wolves are more social. They run in significantly larger packs, they engage in cooperative hunting more often and on a larger scale, and they target much bigger game. While coyotes focus on rabbits and rodents, wolves don't focus on anything smaller than a beaver. They take down deer, moose, wapiti, caribou, bison, muskox, mountain sheep, etc.
Coyotes focus much more on scavenging. They are more likely to hunt alone or in pairs, and will even partner up with a badger. The coyote uses his superior nose to sniff out a rodent, while the badger uses his superior claws to dig up the meal they split. Coyotes can prey on sheep, but wolves also go after larger animals that are important to humans: cattle and reindeer.
The home range of wolves is much larger: the book reports a maximum of 13,000 sq km for wolves, but only 80 km for coyotes. Wolves need much more space: They can't get more dense than one wolf per 26 sq km while coyotes get as high as 2 per sq km.
You might counter again that behavioral differences in animals may be influenced by genes, but humans are controlled by culture. Over the years, I've read a number of studies on the heritability of animal behavior. It's often been of rodents--not known for their rich culture. I was stunned to learn that human conduct is influenced by genes just as much as that of animals. Heritabilities for animal behavior typically run from .2 to .4. Studies often give heritabilities for humans higher than that.
To see who we are more clearly, we have got to look at ourselves like we look at coyotes and wolves; as animals, plain and simple.
UPDATE: To clarify, I suspect that the environment is not as important for animal behavior as the heritability studies suggest. For both human and animal studies, anything not genetic gets thrown into the environment component, but it likely contains a lot of measurement error, random noise, and other factors that probably cannot be changed like the term "environment" suggests.
Monday, August 27, 2012
National differences in female partner violence
In this WHO study of ever-partnered women in 10 countries, Ethiopia has the highest percent ever being physically or sexually assault by a partner--71 percent. Japan has the lowest with 15 percent. The authors chalk it up to differences in economic development. I'm not so sure.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Are gun owners mentally ill?
Some anti-gun people think owning a gun is a sign of some kind of mental abnormality. According to General Social Survey data, gun owners ...
-
Via a reader at iSteve, it looks like this might be the vocabulary test used by the General Social Survey. (Someone please tell me if I'...
-
In the comments in the last post , some readers contended that Jews are not ethnocentric. Using the same question I used in the comments se...
-
Here's the second set I promised. A reader suggested that the first set tends to be older, and it is among younger blacks where you see ...