Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Childhood religion and political orientation


I'm currently reading Witness by Whittaker Chambers. He was an intelligent boy who grew up with no religion. Despairing over the world that was dying in the 1920s, he joined the Communist Party as a young man. Also despairing, his brother ended his life with his head in an oven.

These were sensitive boys, but it made me wonder if being smart and growing up with no religion is a risk factor for radical politics.

The graph shows current political orientation by religious affiliation when the respondent was age 16. I limited the analysis to whites and to those with a perfect score on a vocabulary test--a decent measure of IQ.

Those who were either Jewish or nothing as teens are more likely than Christians to be extremely liberal. (I'm afraid "communist" is not an option.)   

(It's stunning that only 9 percent of smart people raised Jewish are slightly conservative, conservative, or extremely conserative.)

But notice how people growing up with no religion are also more likely than others to be extremely conservative. The difference is not statistically significant, but it is possible that being raised Christian has a moderating effect on one's politics.




3 comments:

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
mengbomin said...

Makes sense. Christianity is the societal norm and thus a child raised with no religion is one raised with views outside the norm and would be more comfortable harboring other views outside the norm.

Obviously that's only one facet of a complicated picture, but I think it fits.

silly girl said...

"(It's stunning that only 9 percent of smart people raised Jewish are slightly conservative, conservative, or extremely conserative.) "


Also, 9% of all American Jews are Orthodox, but 27% of American Jews 18 and under are Orthodox. So maybe in ten years, there will be some shift in Jewish identification with conservatism. I think there is a very young Orthodox Jewish man, a republican, serving in the New York State House.

http://www.simpletoremember.com/articles/a/WillYourGrandchildrenBeJews/