Sunday, June 05, 2011

Agnostics and Big 5 personality traits

Readers SFG and HBD Chick suggested that I compare the personality traits of agnostics with non-agnostics (MIDUS data, sample size = 3,960).


Mean scores

Extraversion
Agnostics 2.82*
Others 3.10
Cohen's d .49

Negative emotionality
Agnostics 2.15
Others 2.09

Agreeableness
Agnostics 3.23*
Others 3.45
Cohen's d .44

Conscientiousness
Agnostics 3.36*
Others 3.49
Cohen's d .29

Openness to experience
Agnostics 3.17*
Others 2.90
Cohen's d .50

*Agnostics and others are significantly different

Compared to the general population, agnostics are more introverted, less agreeable, less conscientious, and more open. They are like atheists, only shy and neurotic.

7 comments:

  1. Nanonymous6:33 PM

    They are like atheists, only shy and neurotic.

    Of course! 100% predictable. Because agnostics ARE atheists, they just don't want to admit it.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Some truth to that, though I don't think I can jump off the cliff and say God definitely does not exist. There COULD be a God, I don't know.

    ReplyDelete
  3. These differences are quite believable, though know that agreeableness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism are those self-reported traits most affected by social desirability (self-deception) and impression management goals (other-deception), and therefore different levels of various kinds of deceptiveness across these groups will lead to a distorted view of the magnitude of difference. Is it plausible that agnostics are less (or perhaps more) self-deceiving or duplicitous than others to your mind? I know of no study which tests this directly, off the top of my head, but it's something to think about.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I found that convinced atheists (and also devoutly religious) were less depressed than 'not sures' in two independent (but small) samples

    http://qjmed.oxfordjournals.org/content/98/11/840.1.full

    and we later found work from another group that reported the same.

    However, when we later tried to replicate it again, the effect (if present) was weak and did not reach conventional significance.

    It is somewhat frustrating to work in this area of psychology of religion/ atheism!

    ReplyDelete
  5. thnx, inductivist! (^_^)

    "Compared to the general population, agnostics are more introverted, less agreeable, less conscientious, and more open. They are like atheists, only shy and neurotic."

    yeah, that's me alright! on some (silly, online) big 5 personality test i scored really high on introversion, low on agreeableness, and very high on openness. i scored pretty high on conscientiousness, tho.

    @nanonymous - "Because agnostics ARE atheists, they just don't want to admit it."

    that is sorta right, at least in my case. in my gut, i feel there's no god(s). but when i think about, it doesn't make sense to rule out 100% for sure that there isn't a god 'cause what if, you know, he really is omnipotent and hiding himself from us. seems logical to me.

    (ok, ok -- i'm just too neurotic and scared to admit there's no god! (~_^) )

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Of course! 100% predictable. Because agnostics ARE atheists, they just don't want to admit it."

    Even taking your assumption at face value, does this really make it 100% predictable? Sheesh; atheists and fundamentalists are the sorts of people who are right all the time.


    "These differences are quite believable, though know that agreeableness, conscientiousness, and neuroticism are those self-reported traits most affected by social desirability (self-deception) and impression management goals (other-deception), and therefore different levels of various kinds of deceptiveness across these groups will lead to a distorted view of the magnitude of difference. Is it plausible that agnostics are less (or perhaps more) self-deceiving or duplicitous than others to your mind? I know of no study which tests this directly, off the top of my head, but it's something to think about."

    This is an decent point, Cultural Wallflower - as much as I love personality data because it is, after all, data, self-report questionnaires are still subject to significant sources of systematic error; this can be seen when one notes the strange findings that that US states showing greater Conscientiousness are less healthy, or that East Asian nations are low in Conscientiousness. It is much better if one can combine self-report data with other-report data.

    Still, I generally prefer to let the chips fall where they may. If Agnostics are Neurotic, maybe there is a reason. I have read (I cannot remember where) that atheists and theists draw comfort from the certainty of their beliefs; it would seem plausible that gazing nakedly into the unknowable cosmos would leave a person feeling less secure. It is probably much easier to close one's eyes to possibility, and be driven by doctrine rather than data.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'm 15 years old. I was born with HIV my mother passed away because of the HIV infection And I regret why i never met Dr Itua he could have cured my mum for me because as a single mother it was very hard for my mother I came across Dr itua healing words online about how he cure different disease in different races diseases like HIV/Aids Herpes,Parkison,Asthma,Copd,Epilepsy,Shingles,Cold Sore,Infertility, Chronic Fatigues Syndrome,Fibromyalgia,Love Spell,Prostate Cancer,Lung Cancer,Glaucoma., Cataracts,Macular degeneration,Cardiovascular disease,Lung disease.Enlarged prostate,Osteoporosis.Alzheimer's disease,
    Dementia.,Tach Disease,Breast Cancer,Blood Cancer,Colo-Rectal Cancer,Love Spell,Ataxia,Arthritis,Amyotrophic Lateral Scoliosis,Fibromyalgia,Fluoroquinolone Toxicity
    Syndrome Fibrodysplasia Ossificans ProgresSclerosis,Weak Erection,Breast Enlargment,Penis Enlargment,Hpv,Diabetes Hepatitis even Cancer I was so excited but frighten at same time because I haven't come across such thing article online then I contacted Dr Itua on Mail drituaherbalcenter@gmail.com/ . I also chat with him on what's app +2348149277967 he tells me how it works then I tell him I want to proceed I paid him so swiftly Colorado post office I receive my herbal medicine within 4/5 working days he gave me guild lines to follow and here am I living healthy again can imagine how god use men to manifest his works am I writing in all articles online to spread the god work of Dr Itua Herbal Medicine,He's a Great Man.

    ReplyDelete

Which ethnic groups think astrology is scientific?

It is important for America that we have people who understand and value science.  The General Social Survey asked people residing in the US...