Saturday, February 17, 2007

Are cell phones the reason for the 90s crime decline?


Steve Sailer has suggested that the spread of cell phones in the 1990s helps explain the concurrent drop in crime since youths contemplating a life of crime might think twice if witnesses can easily call the police during the commission of a crime. I found this graph which shows steady growth in phone ownership in America during the 1990s, especially after 1992. Robbery, for example, peaked in 1991 and dropped until around 2000, so there is a rough correspondence here. Plus, my impression is that young people--those most likely to be victims and, presumably, witnesses of crime--were the first to jump on the mobile phone craze.
Roughly half of Americans now have a mobile phone, so one could argue that if their availability were important we should have seen a drop that continued until the present day, instead of the observed plateau. But it might be that beyond, say, a 20-25% cell phone prevalence rate, additional phones would not make much difference. Only 4 random people would need to witness a crime for one to have a phone handy. Such a risk might be too high.

11 comments:

Tex said...

The theory predicts that the fall in crime should be more dramatic in those categories of crime more sensitive to phone use by a witness. This pattern would also be evidence that suggests causation.

tex said...

Seems to me that embezzlement would be particularly insensitive to phone use.

Anonymous said...

Mobile phone ownership has also created two new crimes. The stealing of mobile phones and 'happy slapping' the filming of otherwise pointless assaults on mobile phones.

Steve Sailer said...

There hasn't been much cell phone inspired violent crime in the U.S., unlike in Britain where muggings to steal cell phones became a big problem.

Fred S. said...

If this were the case, the reduction would be most marked in so-called "contact crime" (robbery, assault, etc.). Property crime, however, has fallen at a greater rate than violent crime in Europe and N. America.

Furthermore, (if memory serves) cell-phones only reached a critical mass in the late nineties, precisely when the decline in crime began to fall or even reverse itself (at least in some categories).

Changing technology has had some interesting repercussions in the criminal realm (improved printing and copying have lead to an explosion in counterfeiting) but this explanation seems specious.

Anonymous said...

I was the 7:20 anon above, I should have pointed out that Im British.

I think the take up of mobiles in the UK is or was much greater than in the US. I worked with an American (from SF, not the middle of nowhere) 2000/2001, he was struck by the level of mobile ownership & use - all but universal here by that stage - compared to back home.

Dont quite know what the crime implications of that are though...

Anonymous said...

I stopped a guy beating up a homeless person (who'd insulted his girlfriend) by saying I'd call the cops. I didn't even have my phone with me. I was standing at a safe distance though.

Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.hadigel.net/program/Program.asp?id=1964]need for speed[/url]

Anonymous said...

High hopes this area is really the appropriate page to submit this... I only wanted to let anybody across the forum who lives in Oz know about a perfect high quality audio visual equipment on-line store named Ordio. I encountered them totally by mistake when I was shopping around for [url=http://www.ordio.com.au]digital radios[/url] and it just so happened that these guys had the least expensive prices around. Not only that but they are genuinely helpful and even followed up on my purchase to make sure I was still happy. They actually buy out considerable inventories of high end audio visual equipment so that they can ultimately break the price down. Definitely give their website a look-see if you're in the market for some home electronics.

Tito

Corrymmip said...

Seems to me that embezzlement would be particularly insensitive to phone use.

Anonymous said...

Τhank you for any оther іnformative
site. Τhe plаcе else mау juѕt І get that kіnd of іnfο wrіtten in such аn ideal mеanѕ?
I hаvе a mission that I am јust now runnіng on, and I
hаѵe been at thе look out fοг such info.


Also viѕіt my blοg post .
.. New York Life insurance