Tuesday, December 27, 2011

Racial differences in felony sentences

Using various sources (NCVS, UCR, BJS), I put together three tables which help explain why state prisoners are roughly half black even though African Americans are only 13 percent of the U.S. population. The disparity is divided into differences in commtting serious violent crimes (i.e., robbery, aggravated assault, and rape/sexual assault), differences in the chance of arrest, and differences in the probability of conviction. (One limitation is that government statisticians are idiots and lump Hispanics in with whites, so "whites in the following table actually means "whites plus Hispanics.")

For all three types of violent crime, most of the racial disparity is due to blacks committing crimes at much higher rates. You might think this is obvious, but many liberals think the gap is due to a racist criminal justice system. Some of the difference in convictions is due to a greater black risk, given a crime, of being arrested. Some of this might be due to lower average black intelligence which leads to riskier crimes.

Finally, little or none of the racial gap is due to blacks being more likely to be convicted of a felony (which is likely to land one in prison for at least a year). In fact, given an arrest for rape, a white man is more likely to be convicted than a black man. This might be, in part, due to less willingness of African American  jurors to put a fellow black behind bars for a crime that can be difficult to prove. Or perhaps victims of black offenders--often black themselves--tend to be less reliable.

Overall, if liberals are bothered by the racial disparity in prison (myself, I care about punishing bad guys), the data suggests that they should focus on black criminality, not the system.


  1. One problem with HBD is that of free will. Liberals presently disbelieve in biological determinism, but genetics is based upon that principle. Stephen Hawking in The Grand Design argues that causality fits all features of reality but we can exercise options even if causality rules.Genetic differences in aggression and criminality-if accepted publically by science- would encourage even more excuses by liberal lawyers using the " had to do it" explanation. Naive white beliefs about blacks play into much mayhem but acceptance of biological determinism could undermine the criminal justice sytem.That human brains work very differently in different cultures is a supreme reason for preventing absorption of diverse peoples. It could lead to weak, ineffectual legal systems like much of Europe or systems excusing violence for genetic reasons. Diversity is best viewed from a distance.


Smart people are more varied than other people

I showed in an earlier post that, according to the General Social Survey (GSS), the smartest category of people are also the most diverse i...