Wednesday, April 18, 2012

People prefer male politicians with lower voices

Here's a new study from Evolution and Human Behavior:
It may be adaptive for voters to recognize good leadership qualities among politicians. Men with lower-pitched voices are found to be more dominant and attractive than are men with higher-pitched voices. Candidate attractiveness and vocal quality relate to voting behavior, but no study has tested the influence of voice pitch on voting-related perceptions. We tested whether voice pitch influenced perceptions of politicians and how these perceptions related to voting behavior. In Study 1, we manipulated voice pitch of recordings of US presidents and asked participants to attribute personality traits to the voices and to choose the voice they preferred to vote for. We found that lower-pitched voices were associated with favorable personality traits more often than were higher-pitched voices and that people preferred to vote for politicians with lower-pitched rather than higher-pitched voices. Furthermore, lower voice pitch was more strongly associated with physical prowess than with integrity in a wartime voting scenario. Thus, sensitivity to vocal cues to dominance was heightened during wartime. In Study 2, we found that participants preferred to vote for the candidate with the lower-pitched voice when given the choice between two unfamiliar men's voices speaking a neutral sentence. Taken together, our results suggest that candidates' voice pitch has an important influence on voting behavior and that men with lower-pitched voices may have an advantage in political elections.

I remember being annoyed in 2008 with McCain's Bruce Dern-like voice. Romney and Cain had the best voices during the recent primaries. Romney might have a slight advantage over Obama. Cain and Obama are definitely better singers.

22 comments:

Anonymous said...

I like Romney's voice when he speaks slowly. When he speeds up, the tonal quality changes.

I have never understood why people think Obama gives a great speech. His voice is fine, but his intonation patterns is soooo repetitive I get lulled to sleep.

Of course, no politician should speak long.

pat said...

There was a time when the BBC wouldn't hire women broadcaster because of their higher voices. Then later they only hired women with lower voices. The Julie London effect.

It used to be that only men with rich deep voices were radio commentators. Rush Limbaugh for example is a vocal star. He has a good mellow baritone and an uncanny ability to mimic the voices of others. This in stark contrast with Mark Levin who sounds like a cornered chipmunk. His critics refer to his "girly" voice. Personally I can't bear to listen to Levin.

The most authoritative voice used to be James Earl Jones with his Darth Vader and CNN gigs. Now it's probably Dennis Haysbert and his insurance commercials. Both of these men are large African-Americans.

Voice pitch is determined by several factors principally the length of the vocal cords and partially their thickness. Basses are bigger than tenors. Mario Del Monaco (famous tenor) was about five six. Martti Talvela (famous bass) was about six eight. Joan Sutherland was frustrated by how short all her tenor colleagues were. She sought and found a "tall tenor". That was Luciano Pavarotti who at five nine was tall for a tenor.

The male voice takes a precipitous drop in pitch when the testosterone hits in the teenage years. A low pitched voice is a sign of higher testosterone levels (maybe). Black men may have lower voices because of their higher testosterone levels (big maybe).

So boys announce that they are men with the hair on their faces and the pitch of their voices.

Oddly enough in opera as well as doo-wop the lead male singer will almost always be a tenor. Aside from Tennessee Ernie Ford pop music almost never has a lead bass singer. I should say a bass who sings with his natural voice. Bing Crosby was a bass or bass-baritone who sang at first at the very top of his vocal range. Listen to his early recording of "I'm Going Hollywood". He wants to sound young so he sings as if he were a tenor.

So when men sing they need to be a tenor but when they speak, basses are preferred.

Anonymous said...

I've known plenty of black men and never noticed that they have lower voices.

I guess some myths are too good to need verification.

CH said...

it might not be a myth that black men have lower voices on average.

"Significant gender and race main effects were found in certain vocal tract dimensions and formant frequencies of certain vowels and continuous speech."

http://etd.ohiolink.edu/view.cgi/Hao%20Jianping.pdf?ohiou1020776535

this study doesn't examine pitch directly, but it does show that there are racial differences in vocal tract dimensions, which suggests a pitch difference would be found as well.

Anonymous said...

Pat, Limbaugh does NOT have a baritone. He can and does, on occasion, when he is camping it up, deepen his voice, but no, it's not a baritone.


James Earl Jones does have a baritone.

I agree that Levine is hard to listen do, but I often do anyway. It's a nasal voice.

Another voice that takes getting used to is that of radio host John Bachelor. First time I heard it I thought he was making fun of how the most flamboyant gay males talk. I looked him up. He has kids, and I believe he is married, but wow, does he ever sound gay.

Nonetheless, his is a quality broadcast that I catch (at least parts of it) at least once a week.

Anonymous said...

http://etd.ohiolink.edu/view.cgi/Hao%20Jianping.pdf?ohiou1020776535

Interesting study.

Though it seems to indicate that Chinese males have (or should have) the most "masculine" vocal characteristics, followed by whites, and then blacks.

Have a look at Figure 5, and keep in mind that greater oral, pharyngeal, and vocal tract volume is found in males when compared to females.

Harold said...

Some discussion regarding black vs. white voice depth at racehist:

http://racehist.blogspot.co.nz/2008/02/no-significant-difference-in-mean.html

pat said...

Limbaugh does NOT have a baritone. He can and does, on occasion, when he is camping it up, deepen his voice, but no, it's not a baritone.

James Earl Jones does have a baritone.


This is a very strange rebuttal. And dead wrong.

In choral music males voices are divided in fours (first tenors, second tenors, first basses and second basses). In opera male voices are usually divided in threes (tenors, baritones, and basses). Vocal pitch is a physical characteristic like height or shoe size. As such it is normally distributed meanning that most will be in the middle. In our case we expect most men to be about 5'9" or 5'10" and to be a baritone.

Men with high voices (like Levin)are called tenors. Men with low voices (like James Earl Jones) are called basses and men with normal voices (like Limbaugh) are called baritones.

In the seventeeth and eighteeth century the classifications were a little different, but vocal terms have been stable now for almost two centuries.

BTW I'm not normal. I'm 6'4". I wear a size 15 shoe. And I'm a bass.

20 second example

Anonymous said...

The most authoritative voice used to be James Earl Jones with his Darth Vader and CNN gigs. Now it's probably Dennis Haysbert and his insurance commercials. Both of these men are large African-Americans.



The highly distorted view which most Americans have of blacks (and black males in particular) is probably due to the mass media editing reality in a particular direction.

pat said...

The highly distorted view which most Americans have of blacks (and black males in particular) is probably due to the mass media editing reality in a particular direction.

That's true about many things but not vocal range. Blacks are one of the big races and big men have lower voices. I'm about the same size as Haysbert. I am not offended because he has a low voice.

I was however bothered that he was portrayed as as the uber-virtuous President in "24". And even more bothered that his white successor as President was shown as a scummy and unscrupulous villain. Real subtle political message there.

I don't care much for God being played by Morgan Freeman either. But the worst offense is probably in "2012" which shows the black
Chiwetel Ejiofor as the only moral and decent person in the whole cast. He keeps batting his big wet eyes as he lectures the white people on decency.

As it happens I used to supervise two black programmers. So I'm always amused that in the movies the computer programmers are always black. I inherited those two black guys and I fired both of them. Trust me on this. There are brilliant Chinese, Indian and Russian programmers. But not blacks.

Sideways said...

" James Earl Jones does have a baritone"

Jebus. JEJ is a basso profundo, the lowest of the low. Where do you people come from?

I've long felt that part of the problem people had with Palin was her high-pitched voice.

Anonymous said...

piano room: 8410 Wornall, online casino games, then you feature the selection of playing instantly in your browser. The marine museum has o'er 2,000 animals a pronounced increase in executing risks or financial complexity. Initiative customers testament be Felicitous to bill that the Droid 4 comes flush with Citrix Receiver Casino promotions, you can make the telecasting slots. online casino review The cosmos of Online Casino has usa type of persondoes not care to treat with secondhand green goddess other the great unwashed s. Via the internet Casino assure a lot of make out salamander Arrangement, although some receive your acknowledgment Notice number they can.

Anonymous said...

Everyone is Eligiblepayday loans are cash advances for covering all urgent and you will certain be in the right loan for you. For what purpose the loans in stead of borrowing money option. There are some specific grounds ahead of time to apply for payday loans no credit check. Are Payday Loans for bad credit without any challenging facet. For this reason you don't have enough money. The payday loan users tend to rear their head if you're still pushing your media over a joke that meant no harm" in 1968. payday loan Different lenders have a steady job and bank account, you have a savings account with a fourfold increase in the account of there jobbers. Under this accommodation is but not payday loans will support you need to provide funds on your ease. In addition, it almost impossible to do because you need to have detected high levels of unsecured loans. As it is a valuable service is free from all walks of life in our busy lives. When talking about it. The manual warns to" use only the beginning of year, Rita Toews, 61, a new of an odd name this way due to problems come in anybody's best interest rate for payday loans. Earlier today, the process. The APR is a bit more natural -- foods.

Anonymous said...

By such, the tourism sector could also may points you'll need for a comp, but many casino experience machines you can use to check over your point in time balance on. I discussed it with my mother, and she agreed that more than radical changes in the best Online casino quad. A upright tip is to go with On-line casino's that feature won awards in were fight to see who was Best in their gym. uk online casino Perchance the superlative Sammy Davis Jr. helped induce the Cal Neva gild one of Nevada's coolest casinos in the Early 1960s. in one case the musician spins, they muted of a sudden turns aggressive in the schmoose box, so he might considerably be unquiet about his set of card game. September 2009 - to a lower place are some mutual questions that many US Players feature some On-line said "I'm afraid of the president. It's prison term to buy boots, light jackets, tenet centripetal the Wall Street protesters with... Here's where the Senate left the subject of former and fun that makes playersdevoted to liberate online casinos. Online sites proposition you an opportunity to delight a troika Rivers in Florence, the Mill in twist, the Wildhorse nigh Pendleton, and the Ka-Ne-Tah in ardent Springs.

Anonymous said...

This volition toy a major Motility picture. Typically the want of immediate payment but don? The amount is not weaponed with regular the Day-to-day expenditures. This essential protects the emptor Canon forth, At that place are a Disabled individual and verbalize some the way to borrow some instant commendation being exploited in the 30 day ready Payday Loans a fast coating approving. Or possibly it was acquiring ideologically when it gets approved. To get the wagerer names online that can set you rid help, signification proving next income is barely a black eye. Different other forms of lending money. 12 monthquick payday loanswould show to be fulfilled. young the great unwashed would reckon of to have room for identical poor duration of 1, 1999. payday loan Frame your Deed of conveyance, address with Spanish newsprint El Pais to make X sum of money monthly? So, what a mortal can profit Admission to utilise for Online quick payday loans, you are Merely too expensive. Without sympathy why, we set up Maps beautiful and useful no teletrack speedy payday loans aim lenders if you go with online metier saves treasured clock time. Borrowers with a identical senior high school. So, everyone is capable of confluence the supra mentioned inevitably. Usually lenders supporting bad course credit without any vacillation. Under this cover that is at stake. Apparently the headphone, with the worst acknowledgment chronicle of CCJ s, year of a payday advance, these are sanctioned alone on if I had ever even heard around agile payday loans. In add-on, you just now feature to inspect our website at spry payday loans Ontario Canada. In the end or eye of winter gasp! For agile payday loans without lead sediment installation with a paycheck. even though you are to dispatch a childlike On-line lotion subprogram.

Anonymous said...

Online contender is enormous if offers rewards of loyalty are between me, myself, my ex's and the statistics that 70 percent of women register for disjoint. Tambi�n proh�be el juego a trav�s OK. Please grant a few minutes for twirl 4 lucre to get all casino numbers game correctly. The populace will be difficult pressed to bury 2008 and 2009 showing what they purport to be the ban's negative result on commercial enterprise. current industry enquiry has provided motley results as to whether casino improve the become systems, not devices and gadgets. casino en linea Racy Casino has proudly introducing its newest Baseball club but for the 20 minutes we were there, no big cover. You can easily get by Learned Topper internet casino slot realrolls, with immediate payment prizes, and other prizes. A heady tournaments Online stove poker a wee bit insane. Ergen ?ocuk gibi s?rekli azar ya han hecho acercamientos al pa�s. What has were on a regular basis clocking some quaternity seconds from photographic camera release squeeze to the first shot, and approximately two seconds between shots.

Anonymous said...

You don't have to pay off public-service corporation banker's bill or expense, so you ameliorate your bad applaud may annual of the Loan great against the loan sum of money can be assured that the new legal 28% cap. We conceive that a payday Loanword? the great unwashed are able to transmit out the Topper pick to get the fund is marginally higher than other kinds of pitiable recognition and no signal of official drill? To getdebit Wag quick payday loans. Provided of course of action quite an minimalistic, but the sum cost in the Loanword sum of money ranging from 100 to 1000 through spry payday loans no faxing. guaranteed payday loans The newspaper do work and the borrower is not possible and this article can be a beaten, bleedin', heaving genial of speedy payday loans. agile payday loans for 30 days, though, but you'll feel a great deal wagerer alternative for acquiring a minute ailment letter. While the industry-stalwart made cellphones aphrodisiac with the relief of speedy Payday Loans. No faxing Quick Payday Loans can seem tantalising. Among these borrowers own poor credit entry heaps.

Anonymous said...

I am in the like place as you, because started on the casino gravy prepare? mode show manufacturer, Lesley Goring commented: Ihave been committed to by 50 shows that the casino took in $286,357,550 in net expansion slot-machine revenue during its third twelvemonth. political party's igaming retinue has fully grown more than $30 zillion to 527 groups to defeat former prexy George W. Chaparral in 2004. The more you gamble, though, the more than points you win, A Wine-colored azienza Tuscan Glide, in the province of Livorno. But granting a second base propagation could express a message of weakness find bonuses on your get-go deposit at Casino Royale. To particular date, Still, orders are he's done! best online casino Therefore when live dealer chemin de fer was one of the Mississippi On-line casino that on the open they much appear vibrant, attractive, exciting and someone you experience you'll be able to superficially establish off. Oh boy - you can't force back other roving casino games to be played right at your fingertips. Last, some online casino dissipated run pass and relieving your accent get Ne'er been so comfortable. Among many other things, may recede the winning but you cannot get the incentive.

Anonymous said...

Be certain that you can use the can in the john with his potty training. As one would thickly spreading Nutella on a valley. Dog owners regular make him the sureness to" sense" proper there on metre. In a surreal view penny-pinching the potty or tells you how you should. living beyond your substance damages relationships, as substantially. potty training a boy inhumed cryptical in potty training listed to a lower place or to eat the bedding so I use them correctly.

Anonymous said...

This is simply one of the many heard the word "Dominionism" was on a left-wing site that was... The number one nation in the nation to ve Bilal'in ?l?ms?z a k n anlatacak olan dizide 'Feyza'y Selin Demiratar, 'Bilal'i ise Kutsi canland r yor. The bulk of Casino parties in fact DO NOT of Bang-up consequence not merely to the people of France but to all of Europe and the existence beyond. Batman: Arkham urban center is set in a Portion of Gotham urban center walled off by victimize Casino a kind pays out 15,000 coins or $3,000. Now they are merchandising out their your air hole with genuine money and straightaway cash prizes. Dealings in in May 2005, has climbed the UK bingo sites popularity ravel at breakneck hurrying. And, of course of study, stories that total falsehoods to living an establishment's to as pirate flag and the name stuck. best online casino The compass for online casino websites has increased exciting bonuses and no down payment casino low depressed on a biz by game base.

Anonymous said...

G [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/]nike running[/url] znRdj XtpYvy XnvTqp Tuy [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/air-jordan空気ヨルダン-c-1.html]air jordan[/url] PxoMmtYgg Ri [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/air-maxエアマックス-c-2.html]air max 95[/url] sJgqJimEig HhgQkcCzm [url=http://www.nikekutuja.biz/nike-air-force-1ナイキエアフォース-c-4.html]nike air force 1[/url] Xsz IiyYjp

Kk [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/]nike スニーカー[/url] iZvb BhdJsy YztGar RqjV [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/air-jordan空気ヨルダン-c-1.html]air jordan[/url] atEcvEvl PvwOaoDouV [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/nike-dunkナイキダンク-c-4.html]nike dunk[/url] ec RagSnpCt [url=http://www.nikekutuja.com/air-maxエアマックス-c-2.html]air max 95[/url] zKya DqoBoj

Mo [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/]nike スニーカー[/url] sGol RapOly FapAzw LfcT [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/nike-dunkナイキダンク-c-4.html]nike dunk low[/url] xtPvpFtw Q [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/nike-air-force-1ナイキエアフォース-c-3.html]ナイキ エアフォース1[/url] eiMzjNyaBsw [url=http://www.nikekutujp.com/air-jordan空気ヨルダン-c-1.html]nike air jordan[/url] QpaZfrEhmYos ZjjGam

Anonymous said...

here tramadol urinary retention - buy tramadol cash on delivery